Finding the perfect edge control for type 3/4 hair can feel like searching for the Holy Grail. With so many products promising long-lasting hold, it's easy to get lost in a sea of claims. This comprehensive review puts twelve popular edge control products to the ultimate test, evaluating their hold, application, scent, and overall performance on type 3/4 hair. We explored a range of textures, from light creams to sticky gels, to uncover the best options for achieving flawlessly sleek edges that last. Each product underwent rigorous testing, considering both wet and dry hair application methods.This showdown reveals surprising results, highlighting the impact of application techniques and individual hair responses. From unexpected disappointments to impressive winners, we’ll delve into the specifics of each product, offering detailed insights to help you make an informed decision. Prepare to discover which edge controls truly deliver on their promises and which ones fall short, saving you time, money, and the frustration of a bad hair day.
Pros And Cons
- Soft hold when wet
- Soft hold, doesn't last all day
- Cotton candy scent (disliked by reviewer)
- Light texture
- Not sticky
- Effortless application
- Soft hold (doesn't last long)
- Strong, sweet cologne-like scent
- Minty scent
- Good hold, lasts multiple days (with natural hair)
- Watery consistency
- Good hold
- Good price point ($12.99 for 4 oz)
Read more: Tresemme Hair Gel: Top 10 Best Picks
Cream of Nature Argan Oil Perfect Edges
My first test was the Cream of Nature Argan Oil Perfect Edges. It boasts an 'extra hold,' but my initial impression was that the texture was surprisingly light and non-sticky. Application was effortless, smoothing my edges without tugging.
However, the hold proved disappointing. After just 15 minutes, my edges were smushed and had no hold whatsoever. The strong, sweet cologne-like scent might be a deal-breaker for those sensitive to fragrances.
Adding a bit of water before application improved the hold slightly, but it still wasn't a long-lasting solution. Overall, this one failed to deliver on its promise of 'extra hold'.
TGIN Teeter & Smooth Edge Control
Next, I tried the TGIN Teeter & Smooth Edge Control. I compared application on both dry and wet sections of my hair to see if moisture level affected the hold.
The product felt thicker than the Cream of Nature, but not thick enough for long-lasting hold. On wet hair, it became overly moisturized, resulting in a soft hold that wouldn't last all day.
The dry side fared slightly better, but overall, this edge control was not a winner in terms of lasting hold for my hair type.
Mix-Chicks Like a Virgin Tamer
The Mix-Chicks Like a Virgin Tamer, with castor and coconut oil, promised a 'firm, flexible hold.' I again tested on both dry and wet sections.
The product had a noticeable stickiness, but after 15 minutes, the results on both sections were promising. It held better on the wet side, demonstrating that moisture aided its performance.
While not the strongest hold, it was a considerable improvement over previous products and a contender for a good option.
Design Essentials Natural Max Edge Control
Next up was the Design Essentials Natural Max Edge Control, with a pleasant berry scent. Its consistency resembled the Mix-Chicks. Initial hopes were high.
However, after application, this edge control also proved to be underwhelming. Even after reapplication, it only offered a soft hold which did not last.
It was neither particularly strong nor long-lasting, falling short of expectations.
Deuce Edge Control Gel
The Deuce Edge Control Gel, with its cotton candy scent (which I personally disliked), was another product that didn't live up to the hype.
It felt slightly sticky and too moisturizing, not providing a strong enough hold to keep edges in place all day. The wet application was particularly disappointing, resulting in a soft hold.
The gel was soft, not offering the firm hold needed to keep my edges styled for an extended period.
Kaleidoscope Miracle Edges
The Kaleidoscope Miracle Edges, with its watery consistency and minty scent, showed more promise. It was applied to both dry and wet hair.
The dry side provided a decent hold, and the wet side, while moisturized, still held well. The overall performance was better than many of the previous products.
This edge control showed a notable improvement in hold, particularly on the dry sections. Despite the watery consistency, it provided lasting hold.
As I Am Long & Luxurious Edge Control
The As I Am Long & Luxurious Edge Control had a pleasant scent and a slightly sticky texture. The application was smooth.
However, after a short time, it started to lift and didn't provide a lasting hold. The uneven hold in different spots further highlighted its inconsistency.
This product was ultimately disappointing, failing to deliver on its promise of long-lasting hold, despite its initially appealing scent and texture.
Style Factor Edge Booster Pomade
The Style Factor Edge Booster Pomade, despite its unpleasant lemon berry scent, had a promising initial appearance. It was applied to both dry and wet sections.
However, it caused significant flaking, requiring the use of oil to remedy the issue. Even after oil application, the hold was inadequate.
The significant flaking and subpar hold made this edge control one of the least effective products tested.
Mielle Honey Ginger Edge Gel
The Mielle Honey Ginger Edge Gel, a previous favorite, was tested again. I used a cotton bandana this time, instead of my usual silk scarf.
The change in method significantly improved the results, with a much better hold and less greasiness. The hold lasted surprisingly well and the cotton bandana proved key.
This product, used with the cotton bandana, proved to be a highly effective and long-lasting edge control, exceeding my expectations.
Eden BodyWorks 24-Hour Edge Tamer
The Eden BodyWorks 24-Hour Edge Tamer (purple top) was another popular choice. Its sticky consistency and pleasant scent were appealing.
This edge control delivered a firm hold on both wet and dry sections, but the scent might be off-putting to some. It held up remarkably well throughout the day.
This product’s strong hold and long-lasting results made it one of the top performers in this review.
Alikay Naturals Lemongrass Leave-In Edge Gel
The Alikay Naturals Lemongrass Leave-In Edge Gel, previously disliked, was retested with a cotton bandana. The hold was significantly improved using this method.
The cotton bandana helped to create a much better hold and prevent the greasiness experienced previously. My edges looked significantly better compared to past attempts.
The improvement was drastic, showing that the application method can significantly impact the performance of this edge gel.
Conclusion: Top 3 Edge Controls
After testing twelve edge controls, three stood out. The Kaleidoscope Miracle Edges provided excellent hold and lasted for days, even though it's pricey.
The Mielle Honey Ginger Edge Gel offered a fantastic balance of hold and affordability, significantly improved by using a cotton bandana instead of a silk scarf.
The Eden BodyWorks 24-Hour Edge Tamer also impressed with its strong hold, although the scent may be a personal preference issue. Each product offers different strengths.